
Proverbs 27:17 says, “Iron sharpens iron, and one man sharpens another.”
At the Willow Creek Global Leadership Summit today, Bill Hybels opened with a powerful talk. He spoke a good bit about the need to have conversations with people on staff who are underperforming, have bad attitudes, etc. We often wait far too long. We often soften the issue. And everyone involved is underserved – the person, you, every one on the team.
In one illustration, he spoke about the most difficult conversations to have – those when the person has served faithfully for a long time (the person he spoke of was there for 20 years), works hard, loves the vision, loves the team, BUT does not have the necessary capacity to grow into where the organization currently is and is going. The complexities, the challenges, the demands have outgrown the person. This is not a black and white situation. Hybels stressed the weight of these situations and spoke of how important it is to move slowly. Put a 6-12 month timeline in place for the person to catch up. Love them, coach them.
But, what if their competency does not get to where it is needed? What if they can’t get there?
Hybels ultimately had to let this person go (with generous severance and an exit strategy).
This issue came up at lunch. Some had significant issues with this approach in a biblical context. How could you part ways and basically fire someone who has served faithfully for two decades?
On the other hand, what if this role is crucial to the vision and purpose of the church (side note – every role is crucial)? What if it limits effectiveness in reaching hundreds or even thousands of people over the next decade?
How do you honor both? Some wondered if a church the size of Willow Creek could have found a different role for this person. But, what if his skill was specialized and there really was no other role? Do you stick them in a role with less responsibility not in their area of gifting or passion? If it’s less responsibility, can you pay them what they were making and call it good stewardship of finances? If you take them out of their area of gifting and/or lower their pay, is that honoring? Could it be more honoring to help them find a better fit somewhere else?
Hybels did not give many details regarding the complexities of the situation. They don’t really matter because every situation like this will be a little different. Ultimately, we have to ask God repeatedly for more wisdom to handle these situations well. We are stewards of all entrusted to us – from the one person to the entire team and the purpose of the entire organization. It is not black and white. I do, however, believe that when wrestling with this tension, you can honor both the person and the greater purpose at the same time every time. It may not all make sense in the midst, but a solution exists. And it won’t always be the same solution. Pray. Seek wisdom from God and others. I believe with prayer, it will become black and white for you as a leader. Sometimes it will mean moving someone to a new role. It could mean creating two roles in the same area. And, sometimes, it could mean asking the person to make an exit strategy to leave the team. Welcome to leadership.
The conversation was very engaging at lunch. Everyone voiced opinions. It did not ever get loud or disrespectful. There was a little tension though. A little heat.
And there has to be heat. Iron never sharpens iron without it. Welcome other opinions. Welcome the tension. Be thankful for others.